← Back to the screen

Design system portfolio

Design record: Requisition approvals

The four direction lines behind this page, the generator command that produced its tokens, and the pairs it was measured against.

A purchasing manager at a two-plant manufacturer clears the queue of requisitions waiting on their signature.

Direction

Floorplan. List Report → Object Page, held together by a Flexible Column Layout. Fiori's default pairing, and the one floorplans.md says to reach for first.

Archetype. Split. Both halves stay live, so the queue never disappears behind whichever record the manager is deciding.

Data stance. Table-first. The queue is the product; the object page answers the one question a row raises.

Density. Cozy, at a 36px control and a 44px row. Not Condensed.

The one bold thing. The text/element split, shown side by side: a budget bar in --sapNegativeElementColor with its label beside it in --sapNegativeTextColor.

Generator

sap_tokens.py --both      # produced tokens.css
sap_tokens.py --density
sap_tokens.py --semantic
sap_tokens.py --grep Duration

tokens.css is unedited: re-running --both reproduces it byte for byte (diff -q clean).

Why Cozy

--density reports Condensed at 22px control / 24px row and exits 1 while that stands, against SC 2.5.8's 24×24 floor. 2.5.8's Spacing exception wants a 24px-diameter circle on each undersized target's bounding box to clear its neighbours; in a packed queue with a checkbox in the first cell, it does not. Cozy clears the floor outright and serves touch as well as a mouse.

Measured in Chromium at 1440×900: control 36px, the single-line Items rows 44px, the queue's two-line item 52px (Cozy's two-line ceiling is 80px). Every target passes wcag_check.py --target at AA.

The two states

  1. The queue. Nine requisitions, with the first one open in the object page.
  2. A bulk approval that only partly lands. Check every row → Approve → a confirmation naming the count and the total → "6 of 9 requisitions approved. 3 need a second approver", each of the three named with what to do about it, the three remaining rows marked Held, and the object page switched to the first of them carrying its own reason and a changed primary action. This is the state patterns.md says an enterprise bulk action owes the user, and the one a split floorplan makes hardest, because both halves have to agree afterwards.
  3. The queue empty. Each held row's primary action names its own destination (the CFO office, 4712-FAC, Legal) routes it there and takes it off this desk, so three more clicks reach nothing. The list says Queue clear rather than reusing the search's copy, and the object column empties with it: a split whose right half keeps a live Approve on a record that has left the queue is telling the manager two different things at once.

Reject and Ask for information are real on both the toolbar and the object page; nothing on the page is an inert control.

The uplift pass

What the page does now that it did not:

Deviations from CONTRACT.md §1

Round two: the first screen

Round four

Round nine: the approver's pass

Driven as the approver (select, approve under the limit, over the 100.000,00 EUR limit, reject, ask, multi-select, every popover and dialog, the three sections, expand and close), then at 360 and 390 on an emulated phone, at 200% zoom, in both themes and at 1920. Arithmetic re-checked from the data: nine rows sum to 439.220,50; items 29.100,00 + 19.650,00 + 41.650,00 + 28.000,00 = 118.400,00, 18.400,00 over; quantities times unit prices agree; 14.09.2026 is a Monday and no due date falls on a weekend.

Scores, ten heuristics 0 to 4: before 26, after 30. Below 3 after: help and documentation (2), because the page explains states only where they happen.

Boson

boson.mjs copies index.html alone into its run folder, so the linked tokens.css goes missing: run on the file as it stands it reports Times New Roman on 99.6% of the text, 21px-high buttons and "no focus indicator" on every control, none of which is the page. Run on a scratch copy with the tokens inlined, it reports the keyboard probe at 0 findings and no contrast or target findings. What remains is deliberate or out of scope: sticky bars inside the two column scrollers (that is the floorplan), four fixed leadings kept in rem for alignment, and launch checks (privacy policy, share image, 404 page) that belong to a site, not a specimen.

Round ten: help, and a way back

Scored first, ten heuristics 0 to 4, then driven as the approver at 1440, 390 and 360 (emulated phone), in both schemes. Round nine's one score below 3 was help and documentation (2): the page explained a state only where it happened. Fiori's own answer is a Help entry in the shell, an info button with a popover beside the term that needs it, a tooltip on every icon-only button, and keyboard paths for the decision.

Scores: help and documentation 2 then 3; the other nine held, so the total goes from 30 to 31 and nothing remains below 3.

Left: the Horizon semibold family falls back to Arial for visitors, so the weight-600 titles render at regular weight in the shell and the list. SAP licenses 72, so this is the page's stated deviation, not a defect to patch.

Round eleven (2026-11-10)

An independent reviewer scored 34/40 and found two severity-2 defects and one severity-1, all reproduced before editing.

Invented: nothing in the product. One layout rule (a decision returns to the queue), named above.

Round thirteen (2026-11-10)

An independent reviewer scored 35/40 and said it would ship, with one gap: "the split does not hold the next record after a decision." Reproduced at 1440 light: open Vacuum, Approve, and the object column closed, nothing was selected and the next record needed a click.

Invented: nothing in the product. Two small rules, named above: the 700 ms pause after a decision, and the previous record opens when the last one was decided. Not changed: Ask for information keeps the requisition in the queue, so it stays open; a partly landing bulk approval still switches to the first held record.

Round fifteen (2026-11-10)

An independent reviewer found one severity-2 defect and four severity-1 notes. The severity 2 reproduced as reported before editing.

Invented: nothing in the product. One page rule, named above: a requisition a decision opens is unread until the approver scrolls it, touches it or moves focus into it, and its decision buttons wait until then. The hint line is the one new string.

Round seventeen (2026-11-10)

An independent reviewer scored 36/40 and found one severity-2 defect and one remaining severity-1.

Invented: nothing in the product. Two small rules, named above: "decided just now" counts what the last undoable decision settled, and the next record offered is the one that followed the open one.

Round nineteen (2026-11-10)

Round twenty-one (2026-11-10)