One completed route: its elevation profile, its map and its eight splits, as one screen that changes shape. On a phone it is an iPhone screen: a large title that collapses into the bar on scroll, three views (Route, Splits, Log) behind a floating tab bar. From 1024 px it is the iPad and Mac split view: the splits as a sidebar, the route filling the pane beside it.
Direction
- Archetype: app screen, not a document. The device frame is the layout.
- Data stance: chart-first. The elevation profile leads, shaded by the grade of each hundred metres, with a drawn map beside it that follows the same position. The splits are a list a finger can hit, and each row moves the profile and the map to its stretch.
- Density: generous, on a four-point grid. Every control clears 44 pt with 8 between neighbours. Radii nest: a 12 pt row sits inside a 20 pt panel with 8 pt of padding, and the text-size sheet is 24 over 12 with 12.
- The one bold thing: Dynamic Type, honoured. The size sheet drives the real ramp up to AX5, where the split view folds into one column, the map grows taller and sheds its secondary labels, the back label becomes a chevron and the tab labels stop at 28 pt.
What changed in the uplift (2026-10-29)
- Composition. A one-column document became a large title, a distance figure with three supporting figures, a topographic map and the profile. The elevation profile is the lead and the splits table became a list.
- The scrub. The profile is a slider: pointer drag, arrow keys, Home, End and Page keys,
aria-valuetextcarrying kilometre, altitude, grade, clock time and split. A lens follows the finger. The readout, the map position and the highlighted split all follow the same value. A row click or a map click glides to that point; under reduced motion it jumps. - The map. Drawn in SVG at the size it is shown, so strokes are never scaled. Contours come from marching squares over a terrain built as the upper envelope of cones around the route, so the contours agree with the profile. Gap in the signal: a dotted line, as on the profile.
- Liquid Glass, only where the HIG puts it. The bar once content passes under it, the tab bar, the text-size sheet and the lens under a finger. The cards, the map and the rows are plain surfaces. It is a browser blur, not Apple's material, and it falls back to an opaque surface without
backdrop-filter, underprefers-reduced-transparencyand underprefers-contrast: more. - Large title. An IntersectionObserver collapses it into the bar; the bar title fades in.
- Data. Distance, ascent, moving time and clock time add up: 18.4 km, 1,240 m up, 3:38:30 moving of 5:15:00, with four stops that sum to the 1:36:30 between them. The old Iron Creek to Marsh Bench pace read 9:41 and was arithmetically 9:40.
- Entry motion (rise and route draw) only under
prefers-reduced-motion: no-preference.
Generator
hig_type.py --responsive # tokens.css
hig_type.py writes tokens.css. The page links it and never edits it.
The AX3, AX5, and xxxLarge overrides inside index.html come from the same script, one run per size, and the checks behind the layout come from three more:
hig_type.py --size xxxLarge # and --size AX3, --size AX5
hig_type.py --all-sizes --format table
hig_type.py --targets
hig_type.py --concentric 16 8
Colour
hig_type.py emits no colour, and Apple publishes no colour token values. The HIG's first rule on colour is that the documented ones "may fluctuate from release to release", so nobody may transcribe them. The page's semantic set therefore comes from the web's own system colours, Canvas and CanvasText, with color-mix() for the three label levels and the separator, modelled on the HIG's label and grouped-background hierarchies. One custom accent carries both appearances through light-dark(), and it is the only literal pair. The appearance switch sets color-scheme, and that flips all of them together.
Measured on rendered pixels in this uplift (computed foreground against the painted background pixel, WCAG relative luminance):
- Tertiary label on the page ground, the tightest pair: 5.22:1 light, 6.45:1 dark. On a card it is 5.74:1 light and 5.70:1 dark.
- Secondary label on the page ground: 9.80:1 light, 9.92:1 dark.
- The accent on a card, which paints the route and the links: 6.49:1 light, 8.29:1 dark.
Apple's own secondaryLabel and tertiaryLabel are lighter than 4.5:1 by design. The three levels here are set by measurement: the shallowest mixes that clear AA against the worst ground on the page. The selected split row is an opaque mix of the accent over the card, not a translucent wash, so a measurement of its text has one background to read.
The hatch over the gap is deliberately faint. It is a texture behind a fact the dotted line, the notice, the list row and the readout each state in full, and giving it enough weight to pass would put more ink on the absence of data than on the data.
Two overrides on the generated type
Both live in the page, never in tokens.css, and both leave size, family and weight with the token:
- Running prose is set to 1.52 leading. The text styles carry Apple's 17/22, which is a control label's leading under a 70-character line. The override is scoped to prose elements, so
font: -apple-system-bodystill supplies everything else where Safari honours it. - Display tracking resets to normal under
@supports not (font: -apple-system-body). The −0.01em intokens.cssis SF Pro's optical-size compensation; that query is false exactly where the stack has fallen through to whatever grotesque the OS has, and a face that is not SF Pro is not improved by SF Pro's tracking. On this machine the whole stack resolves to DejaVu Sans, measured: every candidate name renders at an identical advance width, so the fallback is a stated condition rather than an accident.
The second state
The 1.9 km where the watch held no fix. The profile draws a hatched band with a dotted line between the last and first known points, and the map dots the same stretch. The split row reads No data for ascent and a dash for pace, the scrub handle reads "No data" for altitude and grade there, and the day's total leaves the gap out and says so. Three marks that must not look alike sit on screen together: a measured 0, a No data, and the dash.
Dynamic Type
Built at Large, then measured at Large, xxxLarge, AX3 and AX5 across phone, tablet and desktop widths: no horizontal overflow at any pair. Layout changes at the accessibility sizes follow Apple's guidance rather than patching around it:
- the split view folds to one column with the tab bar, at any width;
- the callouts and axis labels leave the plot, and the range moves into the caption;
- the map frame grows to 4:5, keeps only Trailhead and South Peak as labels, and its two notes move out from over the drawing;
- the back link becomes a chevron, its word kept for a screen reader;
- each split row becomes one column with a thicker bar.
Deviations, stated
- Self-set figures (the distance, the readout, the stat numbers) sit above the generated ramp and scale by a
--dtfactor instead of a text style, because no style is that large. They still follow the size control. - Tab labels are capped at 28 pt at the accessibility sizes. A tab bar is the one place the HIG allows capping, and three labels at 53 pt do not fit.
- The stop times, the party names and the route are invented for the page. The arithmetic is real and checked in the page's own data model.
- The splits table became a list of buttons so each row can be a target.
- The AX3/AX5/xxxLarge ramp overrides are hand-copied from the generator's output, one run per size, as the generator section says.
- This machine renders the whole stack as DejaVu Sans, so the page was measured in a face wider than SF Pro; if anything it is conservative.
Round four
- The chart readout (distance, altitude, grade, time of day) is no longer pinned inside the plot at 1280px and up; it sits above the plot at every width, so it cannot meet the 2,000 m gridline or the "last 4.2 km" callout.
- Phones: a bottom scrim as tall as the tab capsule plus the home-indicator inset (
env(safe-area-inset-bottom)) fades the page out beneath it, so the next section's title is not half-read through the glass on first view. It is a sibling of the capsule, because the capsule's backdrop-filter would make a fixed child of it fixed to the capsule.
Round eight
- "Trailhead" met the scale bar (390 light). Real, and not only at 390: the label's box overlapped the bar's box at 390, 430 and 600 wide and touched it at 320. The trailhead is the lowest point of the route, its label hangs 22px under it, and the bar stood 40px above the frame's foot with only 64px of padding under the route. The padding under the route is now 80px (64 at the accessibility sizes), so the label ends above the bar's top at every width checked (320 to 1440). The bar stays over its "2 km" caption, which is where it belongs.
- The Splits sidebar stayed beside the log (1440 light). Real. The sidebar was sticky inside a grid that also held the log, so it kept following the reader into prose it has nothing to do with. Moving it to the route's grid row did not help, because the sticky range of a grid item here is the whole grid, not its row. The route and the sidebar now share one box (
.board, which does not exist when stacked), the sidebar sticks only inside it, and "On the day" runs across the full width: prose on the left, the four stops on the right. - Declined: nothing. The design notes themselves were already full width in two columns; the lopsided column the critic saw was the log's, which is fixed above.
Round nine (2026-11-09)
Looked below the fold, at 360 and 390, in dark, at 1920, with the sheet and a scrub driven. Found and fixed:
- "Trailhead" sat on the profile line (390, 360, both schemes). The label was anchored 12px over the first altitude, but the line climbs under a long label. It now measures its own width and rides above the highest point it spans.
- The text-size sheet let the tab bar's labels through (390, both schemes). "Route" ghosted into the sheet's last line. The sheet and the collapsed bar now use the 90% glass, not 64%, so a label beneath is a tint, not a second line of text.
- Design notes started 4px left of the page's text column, at every width, and at 1920 sat 24px outside it. The wrap now takes the same inset as the hero and the log, and the bar and notes share the app's 1760px outer edge, so Portfolio, the cards and the notes line up.
- "1.9 km" broke to a lone "km" at 360 in the no-fix notice heading. Thin no-break space between figure and unit in both headings, and headings balance.
- "the false summit → South Peak" wrapped to a lone "Peak"; split names balance.
- The hatched empty bar vanished on the selected row: it is accent-tinted there, so the no-data stretch keeps its mark when selected.
- Left: the vertical scrub line passes through the "No signal" label when the handle is mid-gap (halo keeps it legible; taste).
Round ten (2026-11-09)
A cold second read, scored 31/40 against round nine's 34 (see the report). Found and fixed:
- A tapped split changed a screen nobody could see (390, 360, every size, severity 3). On a phone the profile and the map are on the Route tab, so a row on Splits only recoloured itself. The tapped row now offers "Show km 15.4 on the route" directly under it (44 pt, accent, hover and press states); one press goes to Route, scrolls the profile under the bar and moves focus to the scrub slider, whose readout already carries the split. The offer sits clear of the tab bar at AX5, goes away when the tab changes, and does not exist in the split view, where the pane is already beside the list.
- The four stop times read as clock times (severity 2). "Alpine Lake, km 8.1 34:00" has no header. The list now carries "Where the party stopped" and "Time stopped".
- "of 5:15:00" under Moving did not say what it was (severity 2). It reads "of 5:15:00 elapsed".
- Iron Creek was both the trailhead and a point 2.6 km along (severity 2). The dateline, the km 0 readout and the map description now say "the trailhead"; Iron Creek is only the end of split 1.
- The no-fix notice led with the method, and its "net gain 118 m" contradicted "the climbing is unknown" (severity 2). It now leads with what the total leaves out, and says the two ends stand 118 m apart, which with 1,240 m is the 1,358 m from 640 m to 1,998 m.
- The map answered touch but nothing said so (severity 1). The profile hint now names the map.
- The readout's split line orphaned "summit" at 360 (severity 1). Balanced.
Invention: the "Show km N on the route" action and its wording. It adds no data and no state beyond the existing marker. Left: the scrub line passes through "No signal" (taste, from round nine).
Round eleven (2026-11-10)
Scored 33/40 by an independent reviewer. One severity 2 defect, fixed:
- The Text size sheet could not show its own note at AX5, and the tab bar ghosted through it (390 dark, 360 light, severity 2). Reproduced: at 390x844 AX5 the sheet was 640 px with 702 px of content (overflow auto, no cue), so "...accessibility sizes." was cut; the sheet was a 90% glass with a 30 px blur, and "Log" showed through behind the last line. Also 360x780 (624 vs 702) and, at 1440 and 1920, 650 vs 640.
- Fix. The sheet is now opaque (
--bg-elevated, the HIG sheet surface) with no backdrop blur, and on a phone the page is dimmed behind it by::backdrop(CanvasText at 32%, faded in with the sheet; no dimming at 720 px and up, where it is a popover over the page). Its height is the screen less the status gap and bottom margin (100dvh - 48pxand the safe-area insets; at 720 px and up, the screen less the bar), so AX5 now fits whole at 390x844 (702 px), 360x780 and on desktop. The head (title and Done) is fixed and the body scrolls (.sheet-body) with an edge shade at whichever end has more to read, for the screens too short to fit it (390x667 at AX5: 536 px of content in 453). The two glass fallbacks (@supports, reduced transparency) went, since the sheet is no longer glass. Done, Escape, and a tap on the dimmed page still close it and return focus to the Text size button. - Not changed: the severity 1 notes (hatched bar in dark, the empty left column, the size not being remembered, tab order, tab scroll position). Those were outside the brief given for this round.
- Invention: none of product facts. One rule the brief did not give: a phone sheet dims the page, a desktop popover does not.
The dim behind the phone sheet and the scroll shade read --scrim and --scroll-edge, which use light-dark(): a fixed CanvasText mix lightened the page in the dark scheme instead of dimming it. Measured: the backdrop is near-black at 60% in dark and black at 32% in light.
Round thirteen (2026-11-10)
Scored 35/40 by an independent reviewer ("Yes, ship"); one severity 1 nit.
- The column under the Splits card stood empty beside the profile at desktop widths (1440 and 1920, severity 1). Reproduced: at 1440 the sticky Splits card was 760 px in a 1,129 px board (365 px of bare page under it); at 1920, 740 of 1,209 (about 470 px).
- Fix. Wide, the no-fix notice ("The watch held no fix for 1.9 km") moves into the foot of the Splits card, under the list and the split note, behind a hairline, because it explains split 5 of that list. It is the same node, moved by the layout script (
applyLayout), so there is one copy and it goes back under the profile on a phone and at the accessibility sizes (verified at 800 px and back). The route column then stretches to the sidebar, and the profile card gives the difference to the plot (the plot is now a flex child with the old per-width height as its minimum), so no padding is added. Result: sidebar and route are 1,056 px at 1440 (plot 375 px, was 280) and 1,014 against 1,041 at 1920 (plot 360 px, unchanged). The sidebar no longer has an inner scroller ormax-height: it is as tall as the route, so it scrolls with the page, and it only sticks when the route is the taller column (960 to about 1300 px). - Phones are unchanged: the notice is still the last thing on the Route tab, at the same size and position at 390 and 360.
- Invention: none of product facts. One layout rule the brief did not give: wide, the notice lives in the sidebar, and the sidebar is not height-capped.
- A summary figure broke inside itself at 1100x800 (severity 2, found by the coordinator). "1,240 m" read "1,24 / 0 m", "3:38:30" read "3:38: / 30", "1,998 m" read "1,99 / 8 m". Cause:
.m ddcarriedoverflow-wrap: anywherein a three-column grid, and the split view with the sidebar leaves the route column about 280 px for the three stats, less than the figures need; my notice change did not cause it (the column is the same width without it), but it exists at 1000 to 1100 px either way. Fix. The stat row is a wrapping flex row; each figure iswhite-space: nowrapwith its own min-content as the floor (flex: 1 1 0, so columns stay equal while they fit), and a row that cannot hold three wraps whole figures to a second row. The "of 5:15:00 elapsed" line still wraps (it is a sentence, not a figure). The two xxxLarge grid rules and the AX one-column rule became one rule (AX3 and AX5: one figure per row). Measured with a script: for 320, 360, 390, 600, 768, 900, 1000, 1100, 1280, 1440 and 1920 at Default, Larger, AX3 and AX5 (44 combinations) every stat value is one line (its box height equals one line-height and its text rects form one line), with no page error and no horizontal overflow. Phone Route-tab heights are unchanged (1,942 at 390, 2,002 at 360). - Also fixed, found by that sweep: at AX5 and 320 px the grade ramp legend ("Flat", bar, "20%+") ran 33 px past the screen.
.rampnow wraps and caps at the width of its box. It does not change any wider layout.